Episode   |  231

The Strategists’ Corner: Media mix shifts take more than math

How can healthcare marketers turn measurement into meaningful action? Learn how to reallocate media spend without sacrificing patient volume or losing sight of long-term growth.

Episode Highlights:

Rich Briddock, Chief Strategy Officer at Cardinal Digital Marketing: “The mistake that I tend to see on the healthcare side is someone will cut the budget from the channel before the logistical plan is really laid out and they understand the timing. So they will cut the budget midway through the month. And on paper, they’ve reallocated it to another channel, but in reality they can’t spend on that channel for another 30, 45 days.”

Episode overview

Your media mix model may show where to move budget, but making those changes work in healthcare isn’t as simple as shifting dollars.

In this episode of The Strategists’ Corner on the Ignite Healthcare Marketing Podcast, Rich Briddock, Chief Strategy Officer at Cardinal Digital Marketing, and Ben Dutter, Chief Strategy Officer at Power Digital, pick up where measurement leaves off. They explore how to turn media mix insights into smarter budget decisions while navigating operational challenges, internal stakeholders, and the balance between short-term performance and long-term growth.

In this episode, you’ll learn

  • What to consider before reallocating spend so patient volume doesn’t suffer
  • Why compliance, creative, and timing matter before shifting budgets
  • When improving existing channels makes more sense than investing in new ones
  • How conversion lag and brand awareness influence media mix decisions

If you’re ready to put your media mix insights into action, this conversation will help you make more informed decisions about where and how to invest.

Related Resources

Announcer: Welcome to the Ignite Podcast, the only healthcare marketing podcast that digs into the digital strategies and tactics that help you accelerate growth. Each week, Cardinal’s experts explore innovative ways to build your digital presence and attract more patients. Buckle up for another episode of Ignite.

Rich Briddock: Hello everybody, and welcome back to the next episode of the Ignite Healthcare Podcast and our now infamous mini-series, Ben, The Strategist Corner. Of course, my partner in crime, Ben Dutter, is here with us from Power, CSO. Welcome back, Ben.

Ben Dutter: Thanks, Rich. Always happy to be here. Glad to be a little bit more on the non-hosting seat this time. Love to trade off with you every now and then, so looking forward to that.

Rich: We’re going to be taking it in turns, my friend. We’re going to be taking it in turns. Don’t you worry. We were just having a chat off-air about enthusiasm, and we are going to be very enthusiastic and upbeat about this upcoming topic because we are shifting gears a little bit in our nerd waffle to move on to the next chapter, which is a phrase that we use a lot at Power, the next chapter of what happens once you’ve identified when you are essentially misallocating budget inside of your organization in terms of your marketing efforts. We’re not saying that all marketers misallocate budget. I think we are saying–

Ben: I think I am saying that, actually, Rich.

Rich: I think we are saying that, yes. That’s true. That’s actually what we are saying.

Ben: That’s right.

Rich: I think we’re saying that we all do. No matter what we do.

Ben: I’m a marketer. Me too. Yes.

Rich: We’re all marketers. We all have to spend money somewhere. We all have to start somewhere. We don’t have perfect models. We’ve got to make some assumptions. It happens to the best of us, and it also happens to Ben and I. We covered off on how you can detect, what solutions you can use to better measure, to understand if you’re spending in the wrong places, to understand which tests you should back, which channels you should diversify into, how to avoid misallocation.

Let’s get into the nitty-gritty now about you’ve found out that the media mix through MMM or MMTs is not ideal. What’s the next step then in terms of actually getting alignment inside of your organization to pivot away from those tried and true tactics that everybody believes inside of the building are the things that are driving the results and that we need to be married to? What are some of those practical steps once you’ve proved that’s not the case?

Ben: Yes, that’s always the hardest part, I would say. On a previous episode, we talked a lot about the change management side. If you haven’t watched that one, I think it was Episode 1 or 2. Go and check that one out. I’m going to skip over a lot of the change management piece, which I’ll briefly summarize here. I’m a big believer in agitating the pain, especially within an organization from a finance perspective. It’s the counterfactual of what if you’re wrong? What if you’re spending in the wrong spot?

You said, Rich, all marketers misallocate budget. I think the finance teams out there go, “Yes, tell me about it, right?” Every time they’re always looking to cut the budget because it’s just a cost center to them. It’s not a revenue driver for them in many cases. I think our job has been, in many cases, from the rebalancing, is to talk first about waste.

It’s much more easy, say, you’ve done some incrementality measurement, to eliminate wasted budget rather than add net new. We all want to grow. We all want to get better, for sure, but it’s usually easier to get across to a finance team, to a marketing team, “Hey, this budget you’re spending over here, that’s actually not profitable or not achieving your revenue goals that you want, it’s not contributing much to the business. Let’s cut that.”

The real fun is then you can paint the picture, and I’d love to hear how you guys talk about this on the healthcare side, but paint the picture of, okay, I’m going to take this 10% of budget that we know is not profitable from this channel over here, this part of the portfolio, and we’re going to jam it over here in this other part of the portfolio that’s actually underfunded, and you show them that scenario of, “Look, your budget-neutral, but you’re generating an extra 10%, 30% more revenue,” or whatever the math dictates out with your model.

That’s really what gets teams excited. The marketers get excited because they’re like, “Oh, I can actually show how I’m performing better growth.” Finance teams get excited because their ROI calculations look less grim. To me, is always like step one is painting the picture or the scenario of, from the pain first, “Look at all this money you’re wasting,” and then, hitting them with the solution of “If you put it over here is where your growth will come from.” Yes, what do you guys see on the healthcare side?

Rich: Yes, I was going to ask you just a quick follow-up question to that, and then I’ll definitely weigh in on that, which is I just wanted to ask you a question on something that you just said, which is showing them what the dollars saved could do somewhere else. When you’re saying, “Okay, look, guys, incremental CAC on this 10% crazy high, way above where you want it to be. For every dollar you’re spending here, you’re maybe losing $0.50 or whatever it might be.

I know what you’re going to say. I know what the answer is going to be, but I’m going to ask the question anyway. Do you typically say we should reinvest that over here in channels A, B, and C, or do you say, “Actually, let’s take that 10% and let’s test it into something completely net new.” We don’t know what it’s going to yield, but we know right now you’re losing money, so pretty good bet that this is going to outperform what you’re currently doing right now with us.

Ben: I only get three of these a day, so, this will be my first one. The answer is it depends. I think it depends a lot on, yes, Rich [crosstalk]–

Rich: Pick your card. [laughs]

Ben: [chuckles] It depends on the situation of the business. For me, it’s like I want to be a good steward and a good arbiter of our partners’ finances. If they’re in a really tough spot, which, unfortunately, is a good chunk of brands that I work with, maybe 20% or so, brand 10%, 20% are not doing well financially. There’s a lot more to that than just marketing efficacy. There’s things around operation expenses. There’s things around product quality. There’s things around R&D that they could be investing into.

Marketing dollars and ad dollars is not the panacea that solves it for them. If we can identify that 10% and in a client like that where they’re like contemplating payroll reductions, which I’ve had that conversation many times, it’s an uncomfortable conversation, versus marketing reduction, I’ll cut the marketing all day every time because I want them to build back up from a foundation of strength. In many cases, that is the team. That is the people, boots-on-the-ground.

However, this is where the other half of the “it depends” comes into play. If they’re doing well, they’re hitting their financial metrics, they’re profitable, overall the portfolio– Today, this episode’s about portfolio rebalancing, but the overall portfolio of their media looks pretty good, then usually the risk tolerance is a lot higher because they’re like, “Oh, we got some room to spare.” Yes, we are identifying some waste, but nobody optimized the efficiency to growth.

To me, at least, philosophically, nobody became a big business by being the most efficient. You want to find an opportunity to reallocate those dollars. For me, in a lot of cases, maybe you get no short-term lift on that reallocation, but maybe six months or three months down the road, you get big lift and they have the runway. They have the financial runway to tolerate that kind of slow return.

Rich: Remember, marketers, insights and inferences and learnings are also valuable. I think we-

Ben: Totally.

Rich: -definitely devalue that currency. Yes, I think putting that question back over to us, I think historically, one of the things that we’ve always had to guard against around change management outside of just this sort of institutional bias towards specific channels and the way we’ve always done things is putting out clarity to think about some of those unintended consequences that could happen as we create the change.

I’ll give you guys an example of some of my healthcare marketing friends maybe familiar with, all too familiar with, which is maybe we’re spending on doctor terms, doctor’s names. We find out that spending on doctors’ names is not incremental because if I’m already looking for Dr. Smith, chances are, I’m probably going to convert. If I’m paying for that versus I just rank organically for it, I’m probably not driving any incremental new patients. We may say, “Okay, we’re going to cut that budget. We want to reinvest in social. We want to reinvest in display.” All of a sudden, the internal marketing team is getting phone calls because the doctor is Googling themselves.

Ben: That’s right.

Rich: “I don’t see my ad anymore.” [chuckles] Yes. Okay. There’s a reason for that. That was not a mistake. I think one of the things that we have to do is to think through all the potential consequences and make sure that not only are we communicating them, but that I, internal client, POC, is also communicating that out as well, that this is the change that we’re making and the reasons why. Really, it helps to educate other people inside the organization, other stakeholders, about why we’re doing this and why it makes sense for the business and to dispel some of those preconceived ideas.

Ben: I’m glad you brought up too, because I think it’s even beyond just the change management side too, though Yes, there’s the classic you want to put the billboard outside the CEO’s commute home. That’s the classic one where they say, “Oh, wow. I get to see my advertising everywhere I go.” That’s important for sure, sort of the internal politics. I also think there’s a lot of logistics and operations requirements that people stumble upon accidentally, and it’s too late, and they scramble, like, how much creative do I need to produce?

If I’m taking budget, per your example, Rich, like out of search and putting it into display, for example, search and display have very different creative requirements. Display has some sort of visual or video asset to it, and now there’s a whole can of worms of “Do we have the right assets? Are they contextual? Are they compliant? Do I have the production for this and the timelines?” All these things.

I think a lot of times when you’re identifying portfolio rebalancing, whether it’s for incrementality or not, there’s also just like an operational constraint that you need to figure out, too. Sometimes, some channels, even if they are more creative from an ROI perspective in media, the juice may not be worth the squeeze because there’s all this other collateral that’s required to generate for those.

I’ll give you a very common example we see in the e-commerce side is TikTok. TikTok is a very high-performing channel from an incrementality perspective. If you’re a legacy organization that doesn’t really understand TikTok, you don’t have a creator community, you don’t have a bunch of vertical video expertise or assets, it can become a huge undertaking operationally for them to stand up an organic TikTok and to get into the creators and do all those things.

Yes, maybe the ROI six months from now looks great on that ad spend, but it’s like, “Do I really want to ‘waste’ or spend six months getting all the legwork done?” Of course, I would say, “Yes, you should do that. Sometimes, in some businesses, they’re like, “No, I don’t want to deal with that. I think talking through the implications of a shift are just as important as the spreadsheet warriors of, “Hey, if I just tweak these numbers around, I get more money.” That’s not really how it works.

Rich: The short-term logistical challenge is really important to understand because, to your point, not just about spinning up creative, essentially if I’m going into display and I need to stand up a new DSP, I think a lot of what we see on the healthcare side is you might end up going and trying to launch a channel where tracking from a compliance point of view becomes very difficult. Maybe you want to use a DSP that isn’t natively HIPAA-compliant, and then you have to get a compliance team involved. That takes weeks, maybe months to get approval on.

I think the mistake that I tend to see on the healthcare side is someone will cut the budget from the channel before the logistical plan is really laid out and they understand the timing. They will cut the budget midway through the month and, on paper, they’ve reallocated it to another channel. In reality, they can’t spend on that channel for another 30, 45 days. What do they do? They either underspend, which isn’t great against volume because usually they have a volume goal with new patients, or they realize too late, which is the most common thing that I see, and then they try and jam it all back into search-

Ben: Yes, exactly.

Rich: -with three days left in the month, and drive even worse performance than they would have if they just left it there in the first place.

Ben: Literally, lighting money on fire in that case, where they’re just dumping–

Rich: Exactly.

Ben: We see that a lot in e-commerce, too. In e-commerce and in consumer side, there’s a ton of promos. I don’t think there’s as much seasonality or manufactured seasonality, perhaps, in the healthcare market. I don’t know that as many institutions, say, come and get your healthcare 40% off, but we’re recording the week of Labor Day, and Labor Day is a big sale moment, big holiday weekend for a lot of consumer product brands.

They’re putting 2x, 3x, 5x the revenue on one day that they usually get on a normal Monday, and then they’re trying to put a ton of spend on that same day and not realizing that the spend that day probably didn’t generate the results for that day, maybe some of it, but the vast majority of it came from the days or weeks or months preceding that time period.

The reallocation and logistics of the short-term is really important, too, because you see, for sales on the consumer side, you see these big moments, and it’s like the teams that won Labor Day weekend were spending in August and spending in July. They weren’t spending on September 7th at that extreme degree. I see that on the consumer side, but with healthcare, the time considerations on those conversions is even longer. It’s months. We’re talking about this lots of times, months and months long.

How do you guys handle that? Are there ever times where you’re falling short? Maybe all your channels are great from an ROI perspective, but you’re not hitting the volume, and the recommendation is to spend more. Is there an approach of certain channels around time to impact or time to conversion in healthcare?

Rich: Yes, I think what you’ll often see in healthcare, which I’m assuming is the same case in e-commerce as well, is your demand capture channels will have a very short conversion lag to that initial lead engagement action. Typically, if we are under the pump with conversion volume and we’ve got to turn on the marketing spigot and there is impression share volume that can be captured, even if it’s inefficient, that’s probably where we’ll lean if it’s such a short-term need. PMax, search, et cetera.

It is a valid concern, which is if we need to drive starts that materialize three to six months later– so we have a qualified lead goal, let’s say, that we’re driving in this month, which is really extrapolated from a start goal that happens six months down the road. Essentially, turning on display is going to be nothing. Turning on additional top-of-the-funnel paid social is really going to be nothing for us, even if we could spin it up logistically in a month, which would be very difficult to do per our chat just now.

I think what marketers have to understand again is where we get to this point of diminishing return, which is we’re not going to convert those qualified leads at a higher rate than what we would typically do through search into starts. There’s no magic like, “Let me go and get even better qualified leads that have a higher conversion rate.” The opposite is the likelihood, which is Google and Meta and these channels. They know who the low-hanging fruit is.

If you’re running your Google account correctly, you’re already on the highest-converting terms using downstream activities, not lead-generating activities. When you open up the taps on those demand captures, not only is your CPC is going to start to inflate and you pay more, but you’re also probably reaching traffic that is more tangential. The search queries that the match type is a little bit broader. The search query is a little bit less dialed in to the search intent you’re really trying to capture.

Your conversion rate is going to end up suffering as well. Not only are you paying more on the front end, but you’re most likely converting less on the back end as well. That start acquisition cost, you should be prepared for it to be significantly higher than what your target was, which, again, I’m not saying that’s a terrible thing. You’ve been running campaigns, and you are way efficient, but you’re just a little light on volume.

You’ve got a lot of room inside of your blended CAC to just turn up the dial, and you can still come in within that blended CAC target, even if the incremental CAC is above where you wanted to be, you may still choose to do that, and we have a lot of clients who do choose to do that. The likelihood is you’re probably not hundreds of dollars below [chuckles] your CAC, and so, the volume chase, you’re really offsetting the efficiency ceiling that you’re trying to hit.

Ben: One of the things that we’re seeing more and more with a lot of consumer brands is this return to the fundamentals or return to the old-school brand-building style. Brand is in right now, for sure, in a lot of these businesses, they’re moving up funnel, they’re going on channels like Meta, on YouTube, on TikTok, even TV, I think, direct mail, and out-of-home and all these things that are more traditional media. They tend to be very slow. I would call them like an ad stock, but very slow conversion lag, a latency from exposure to impact.

I think the mistake that people inadvertently make when they run these models and these tests, like MMMs, they see, “Oh, wow, CTV, connected television, has a low efficiency ratio. I’m going to just cut that budget,” but what they’re not understanding is that it actually creates a synergy or a halo over the next six months that the model just frankly just can’t detect because it’s just too diffused. Then they wonder six months from now why things aren’t working.

A lot of times, I’ve seen brands, they run their incrementality tests. They see, “Wow, we spent 30%, 40%, 50% less than we normally would and our month-over-month sales are the same or almost as good. Wow, we just created all this additional contribution margin, and it’s for this month.” [chuckles] Then you accidentally shot yourself in the foot for the next two months because all the spend that you did in September is actually applying to October and November, not to September.

I think that’s a very easy mistake to make even for consumer brands, and why so many businesses don’t want to invest in those upper-funnel tactics because they turn them on, and they say, “I don’t feel it. I don’t see that return in my business.” Then they get more sophisticated. They run a model. They run an MMT, and it says the same thing, but it’s just a fundamental flaw of the statistics of how those upper-funnel tactics can really be measured because they’re over such a long period of time. It’s really difficult to prove that out.

Rich: Yes, I completely agree with that. I think ultimately, and we’re starting to see this more on the healthcare side, you have to pair a top-down planning approach with information that you’re getting from models, with information that you’re getting from MMTs. Ultimately, it’s an average game. If you have 3 million people in your market, that’s your TAM, and suddenly, you’re only reaching 5% of them, even if you’re reaching the right 5% at the point of conversion, you’re probably still not reaching enough prospective patients to convert enough volume.

When you are at that point of conversion, and this is true at the healthcare side as well because it’s a high-consideration decision a lot of the time, and it’s a very sensitive decision and a very personal decision, they want to have heard of you. If they’ve never heard of you, that creates a lot of friction at the bottom of the funnel.

Would you go to a behavioral health group that you’ve never even heard of and be the most vulnerable you’ve ever been with that person when you’ve never even heard of them? Maybe you would. Maybe you would, but I bet you it’s probably much more likely if you’ve heard of that group and you know that they’re reputable, and ideally, your PCP has also said, “Oh, yes. I’ve heard of them, and they’re great.” Then you’re far more likely to convert.

Chasing to the bottom of the funnel and failing to tell the right narratives and create the brand awareness further up the funnel is a losing game. Also, bottom of the funnel, it’s you can’t reach the right amount of TAM by just spending time there. And you never know when these people are really going to need your services. You have to be ever present. To some–

Ben: That’s the challenge with all this stuff. I guess what we’re saying or what we’re thinking out loud here is that there’s more to portfolio and media mix management than just what a model or an incrementality equation tells you. I think there’s a lot to it that is strategic. There’s a lot to it around brand. There’s a lot to it around understanding your consumer, too.

In many cases, I’ve seen from a media allocation perspective, they’re actually reaching everybody in America. [chuckles] We’ll pop the hood on a new consumer brand who comes into power, and it’s like, “Okay, yes, your Meta reach is 180 million adults, and your Google reach is 100 million adults.” It’s like, “Your TAM is maybe 10 million or 15 million people.” It’s like, yes, you’ve probably hit your TAM just through sheer probability in there, but maybe they got hit one time with a Google search ad or a simple display ad or something.

It’s not enough to build that credibility and that trust. I really think at the end of the day that’s what marketing is about. It’s building credibility at scale. You’re there to kind of convince the customer that you’re trustworthy and that your thing is going to solve their problem, whether that’s a medical problem or they’re trying to figure out which rug that they want to put in front of their door mat for Halloween or whatever it is.

Rich: One that is washable. One that is washable.

Ben: [chuckles] That’s right. That’s right. It’s both extremes. I have made a joke earlier, and this’ll probably offend some people, but there’s a lot of spreadsheet warriors out there where they’re looking at, “Hey, if I tweak my–” It used to be ROAS. Everybody was like, “If I tweak my ROAS or my CPA up and down here and rebalance my portfolio, my overall blended revenue is going to be this.”

Now, we’ve evolved past ROAS, and we’re looking at iROAS, and we’re looking at the incremental return, but it’s the same thing, and it’s not reality. The reality is like all that’s doing is looking at the historic performance, and it often doesn’t configure things like your earlier point around diminishing returns. It doesn’t configure things like reach and frequency against your TAM, how many of those customers you can actually realistically capture.

There’s a lot more nuance. I hesitate to use the word “art” because I do think it’s pretty objective, but there’s a lot more nuance to media planning than just strictly looking at it from a iROAS or ICAC optimization lever from an MMM.

Rich: Obviously, when you’re working in a spreadsheet, you can make any adjustment. You can be like, “Okay. Cool. I don’t know, 5% of my CAC, my ICAC ceiling on this channel, I’m just going to move 5% of my budget to Meta.” That’s probably not a practical change to just carve out 5% of your budget and shift it to Meta because it’s probably too small to stand up a whole new channel, if you’re not on it. What are some of the logistics gates around the practicalities of portfolio rebalancing? When does it make sense to actually shift dollars around?

Ben: Yes, I think it comes down to– there’s a lot of methods you can use, a lot of models. More sophisticated models will tell you a confidence interval, and they’ll say, “We’re 95% confident that the results are between X and Y.” That gives you a benchmark to look at. There’s sometimes a power analysis, the old-school statistical analysis on, “Is this even enough for a noise or error percent to be detectable in the scheme of things?”

I think that’s a great starter case. You can throw that into a spreadsheet or into Claude, and it’ll do it for you. That’s pretty straightforward. A very quick rule of thumb for me is just at least 10% of your total portfolio. Just for easy math, if you’re spending 100k a month and you’re doing a 1K adjustment, there’s no shot that’s going to be– I don’t care what analysis tells you. There’s no shot that’s going to be detectable. You’re going to have more than 1% of noise in your performance in a given week or month or whatever period you’re looking at.

10k of 100k, maybe not super compelling, but probably detectable, especially if you’re using some sort of like a model, like a Bayesian time series model or something like that. If you’re using 20% or 25%, that better be noticeable or else you’re really in trouble. You’ve got a lot of non-incremental media.

I think a good rule of thumb for the non-sophisticated marketers out there that are just starting to dabble with this. 10% is a good practical thing. What I actually prefer to look at, though, is more around from a tops-down and bottoms-up approach together. I look at, “Okay, what is the model if I balance the portfolio?” Maybe it is 2% over here and 3% over here and 4% over here and so I’m shifting maybe 15% or 20% of my total budget overall, but then I actually want to go and look at the individual channels to your point around like impression share.

Does Google think that it could take an extra 20% of budget on those terms? Is Meta’s frequency really high, and if I just cram additional budget in there, is that going to actually net me out any new incremental reach of customer? Am I already way over my CPM threshold on a TV buy, or I’m just paying additional money to reach the same people that I would normally reach.

You have to kind of look at it both from a tactical lens, a bottom’s up lens of what can the channels actually even really take, and then what can you do from an allocation perspective as well. That’s the first logic gate. The second gate is– we talked about this earlier is a lot of marketers, they think their execution is either everything or nothing. They don’t think about it in terms of it’s a balance. They’re like, “If only we executed marketing better, if only we had this magical creative or this perfect account structure, this perfect keyword, we could scale to the moon. We could 10x.”

I’ve met many of those, and there’s the opposite, too, where they’re like, “No. We’re executing as best as we can. There’s no tweaks. There’s no optimizations that we can make. It’s all just, say, budget allocation game. That’s the main lever that we have to pull. This channel’s not going to cut it, so it’ll never cut it, and we’re going to just kill the whole channel because we can’t ever fix it.” The reality is it’s somewhere in between those two, is there’s always new tests to run, new creatives to try, new segments to pursue, whatever it is that you can squeeze out.

In our case, we are on the consumer side. We often see iROAS or ICAC improve by 50%, 100%, just from execution, same allocation, but just because we loaded in better structures, better creative, optimized towards actual incremental KPIs as opposed to just platform-attributed KPIs, and we see the results follow. Allocation’s a huge part of it, but execution is a huge part of it, too, but with both of them together that’s important.

Rich: Yes, and I think that is an important understanding, too, that models won’t detect, but you can inform models to understand, and that is our job, I think, as agency professionals, which is, yes, you’ve got paid searches effect share maybe lower than the spend share, but you’re also running it terribly, and the model doesn’t–

Ben: Right. [chuckles]

Rich: The model knows that it’s being run terribly. We have to give it that input, that variable to say– and this is the other thing that comes back to time, and if you think about time as currency, where should you spend your time based on these factors? Which is not to go off piste again, but do I spend my time doing all the logistical work to spin up these new channels because the model is currently showing them as more incremental?

Do I spend my time honing these existing channels and making them more incremental? I think that is really the deciding process that we as marketers have to make. There’s no magic eight-ball that you can shake and one word to be the answer. I know. It’s [crosstalk]

Ben: You thought they worked, right? [chuckles]

Rich: I know. I was going to get you one for Christmas, but I-

Ben: Aw, dang it.

Rich: -didn’t. We’ll have to think of another solution here, but not just for your Christmas present, but also for how we figure out where to spend marketing dollars. Those are the bets that we’re taking. As marketers, that’s what we get paid money to try and figure out. I think the other thing that gets more complicated about that on the healthcare side is we’re working with groups that are– we talked about this briefly when we were talking about MMM and the challenges with MMM, and it’s the same thing with budget reallocation.

Portfolio reallocation is we’re working with groups that want to know– I literally saw this report from a client earlier today, is what’s the plan for these four locations out of the 120 locations that you run? I’m like, [chuckles] “Okay.” Now, the good news, going back to that point about making existing channels more performant, you can, by and large, get that read at a very granular level. You can get that at the service line level. You can get that at the location level. You can get that at a market level. If you’re a multi-brand, you can get that at a multi-brand level.

You can get that at any level. You cannot get reliable, detectable about shifting small amounts of dollars, model readouts at those levels. Really, the levers that you have to pull when it comes down to that level of granularity are optimize the campaigns better, or you’re just taking an educated guess about diversifying media, getting a read, seeing if it’s generally improving, and then making another educated guess to optimize the mix again, or optimize the channel again, and just determining where the best use of time spent is to try and maximize performance.

Ben: I love that, and I think it really depends on the maturity curve of the business. To your other comment around where do you spend your time? If you’re a small business, especially on the consumer side, and when I say “small,” generally, I mean, like sub-20 million in revenue per year. They’re probably spending anywhere from 2 to 5 million in media at that size. Some of you listening to this might be like, “Wow, that’s actually a big business.” Big businesses are spending hundreds of millions in media and millions in revenue.

Let’s say you’re a $20 million a year business, and you’re spending five in marketing all in, focus on one sales channel, one marketing channel, and one avatar or one persona. Make that the anchor, make that the hub of your program, make sure that from an execution standpoint, logistics standpoint, the measurement standpoint, is unlocked. It’s buttoned up. Say that takes up your $5 million budget per year. That takes four.

That remaining million, that’s your test-and-learn budget to your earlier point around, “Hey, we want to identify new opportunities.” Use that to test the learnings that you’ve already had into a similar channel. You don’t go from one end of the alphabet to the other end of the alphabet, you go from A to E.

If you’re really good at– I’m just going to say Meta ads. Maybe your next best obvious one to transition to is TikTok or YouTube Shorts or something like that. You don’t go from Meta ads to TV as your second channel. It requires different creative, different production, different targeting, different media optimizations. When we’re talking about logistics of portfolio balancing, a lot of times, it has to do with the maturity curve of the business and how confident are they in the tried-and-true or the foundational channels.

A lot of brands that come to me, they’re usually in the $40 million to $50 million a year range in revenue, maybe $10 million in media spend, something like that, and they’re really solid on Google and Meta. Then they’ve never been able to crack “into a new channel” because usually, a measurement challenge. They say, “Oh, we tried TikTok and it didn’t work,” or “We tried TV and it didn’t work,” or “We tried YouTube and it didn’t work.”

That’s where I think putting the energy into a channel that you have a very strong confidence should work for your avatar, for your industry, because a competitor does it, or you have some market research that proves it out or whatever. That’s where you invest the time. You don’t go off on some convoluted trying 15 different channels because you read a podcast. Sorry, podcast listeners, that you’re listening to my podcast right now. That it–

Rich: Unless it’s this one.

Ben: [chuckles] Unless it’s this one.

Rich: Yes, it’s just so crazy.

Ben: Yes, that you heard some random brand, saw success with some esoteric channel, and you’re like, “Oh, I want to try that.” No, you got to have a bit of methodology and a bit of a process on, “Okay, we’re really good at this Google search thing, maybe we should try Bing. Maybe we should try ChatGPT ads. What’s the next parallel that we’re similar to in terms of execution?”

Rich: That all sounds great, but going back to your previous example of you got a CEO in the room. He has looked at some audience data somewhere, and he/she is like, “Cool, our TAM is 180 million people, Ben. We’ve got a nationwide dentist group. It’s anybody who has teeth, and they have pets. We do pet dentistry, too. I just want to reach all of them because we can make bajillions. We can be the dentist to the whole of the United States. I want to be on every channel. I want to see our faces everywhere.”

We’ve all had these clients. We’ve all had these clients. Don’t be these clients, by the way, people, but we’ve all had them. How do you convince them to keep it simple, stupid? I wholeheartedly agree with the approach, but how do you rein in their expectations and just say, “Look–” It’s kind of like the Gordon Ramsay Kitchen Nightmares thing. I don’t know if anybody–

Ben: Oh, I love Kitchen Nightmares. Classic.

Rich: “Just do five dishes,” Gordon was telling them. “Don’t do 79 dishes. You can’t do it well.”

Ben: When your menu looks like a phone book, you’ve got a problem, right? Yes. Exactly.

Rich: Yes. How do you get Gordon to explain to these guys that they can’t do 327 dishes?

Ben: I’m not as charismatic or as coarse as Gordon, so I don’t take his approach. Love the guy, but that’s not my approach.

Rich: Probably [crosstalk] anybody in the walk-in refrigerator from the alley. [laughs]

Ben: That’s right. Yes. No, my first instinct is to say pop the hood on the things that take up the majority of their investment. In that example, they think their TAM is 180 million people, and it’s okay. What’s the most obvious channel that they want to execute on? Probably Google search. Let’s call that out. I would guess that’s probably their foundational channel they want to make sure their Google search is really dialed in.

I think that’s where running an MMT, a Match Market Test on Google search and proving, validating that this is very incremental and very impactful, is a great first step. Before you do anything else, just say, “Hey, okay, you believe that this is important, this is where 40% of your budget is going, let’s just prove it out first, and if it is, great.”

Then it becomes, okay, we can ignore that, but in many cases, it’s not great. It becomes rather than testing into new channels, Mr. CEO, let’s just fix the thing that you’re spending 40% of your budget on first, and there’s a whole series of decisions from there that you can say, “Okay, is it the execution? Is it the targeting?” Whatever. That’s one approach is through the test lens.

Another approach is potentially through the market saturation lens. If their TAM is 180 million people, how much have they actually acquired so far? 1%? Is it half a percent? Is it 0.1%? That’s like we’re not going to be able to boil the ocean, so let’s pick a way to shrink that down. The most useful mechanism that I’ve done for clients in the last 20 years now that I’ve been in this business has been reach and frequency.

We have a lot of data since the ’60s that show that the combination of broad reach and multiple touchpoints, what we call “frequency” in the business, a consumer seeing your ad multiple times over the course of weeks or months. Both of those things together is what builds brand awareness, affinity, consideration, trust, et cetera.

It’s like, “Okay, Mr. CEO, in order for you to reach 180 million people four times, you got to be having, whatever that is, 800 million, 760 million impressions, do some CPM math for them and be like, ‘Good luck with that.’ You’re going to be spending tens of millions of dollars to do that, versus let’s focus down, let’s cut this down, whether that’s geographically, channel-wise, demographically.”

We have some narrowing of the audience. We can achieve the same level of frequency on a much smaller baseline, and that will give you a cheaper budget that can prove out, oh, yes, this actually is very incremental. Then it’s easier to scale rather than spread all your budget out in a giant net that never goes anywhere.

Rich: Yes, I absolutely agree. I think that’s where, and again, we’ll save this topic for another time, really doing a lot of audience segmentation and understanding who your most valuable customers are, which I’m sure we’ll do a podcast on, is really important, guys.

Especially in the healthcare space, reimbursement rates differ by payer, they differ by state. You can’t think of every single patient as worth the same to the organization. Segmentation can help you to narrow in on what’s going to drive the business. I know we’ve been talking for a record 43 minutes. Takeaways, Ben. What are some of the key lessons here when we start to move away from being the numbers on the spreadsheet and being that spreadsheet warrior to the actual practical implementation of shifting dollars around? Three quick things of what people should take away from this.

Ben: Yes, number one, I would say understand all the logistics and implications of standing up a new channel or reallocating budget, like we talked about with creative, et cetera. That’s number one. Number two, say understand your customer. If your customer is not on a net new channel or maybe they don’t use a channel that you’re testing in very much, probably not going to get great results out of that channel, so understanding the customer dynamic with the channel is important. Three, not everything is allocation. Allocation and execution both are super critical because the execution is what allows you to scale, and that can completely change the face of your media program. Don’t just get over-indexed on one or the other.

Rich: Awesome. Ben, thank you so much for sharing your insights outside of healthcare on this episode of Strategist Corner. Ben, thank you very much, my friend.

Ben: That’s all right.

Rich: It’s been great to have you again, and we will see you all next time. Thanks a lot.

Announcer: Thanks for listening to this episode of Ignite. Interested in keeping up with the latest trends in healthcare marketing? Subscribe to our podcast and leave a rating and review. For more healthcare marketing tips, visit our blog at cardinaldigitalmarketing.com.

Healthcare Marketing Insights At Your Fingertips

Listen and subscribe to Ignite wherever you get your podcasts.